Panellists discussed ways that municipalities can balance their responsibility to steward parks and civic spaces, respect the legal and human rights of unhoused individuals, and manage the social and economic needs of neighbourhoods.
CityTalk / Canada
Summer Crisis: Are Encampments Coming Back to Stay?
Plats à emporter
Un résumé des idées, des thèmes et des citations les plus convaincants de cette conversation franche
1. Using a human rights-based approach
Leilani Farha explained that when we consider encampments as a violation of human rights, our perspective, sense of urgency, and resource allocation changes. When people living in encampments are recognized as people whose rights of health, life, and ability to maintain employment have been violated, their relationship with government changes. By acknowledging that people are experts in their own lives and have ideas regarding their immediate and long-term plans, we can adapt the way we engage to be more meaningful.
2. Banning encampment communities is not the answer
Councillor Catherine McKenney described how Ottawa doesn’t see as many encampments, due to a different jurisdiction of the lands. However, this doesn’t mean people are not unhoused, but rather that they are forced to scatter. Without encampments, there is also nowhere to deliver services comprehensively. Some alternative solutions Ottawa has explored include the unsheltered task force or respite centres. These services allowed staff to get to know people and their individual needs, developing a more meaningful engagement.
3. There is strength in different governance structures
After joining the Strathcona Park team with Vancouver Parks and Recreation, Donnie Rosa realized the true extent of their role. Vancouver has a separate, independent, elected board who runs the park system. which allowed her and Betty Lepps to take their time developing new collaborations. By following the mandate that no one would be kicked out of the park without having adequate housing secured for them, the team brought a harm reduction lens and created Betty’s formal position as Director of Urban Relationships. They then convened meetings between the city, residents of the camps, Indigenous communities, and health agency Vancouver Coastal Health to bring everyone together under the purpose of providing wellbeing for park users.
4. The role of municipalities
All panellists acknowledge there is a need for intergovernmental relationships due to the complexity of the issue. Nonetheless, they also advocated for redistributing resources and placing the responsibility to end homelessness on the municipalities. Catherine McKenney noted that in Ottawa, they know the exact number of dollars it could take to achieve the National Housing Strategy of reducing core housing needs and ending homelessness. Due to unique conditions in every city, it can be hard to address local needs under provincial rules. Furthermore, Donnie Rosa argued that if municipalities complete all their tasks, the conversation on adequate housing can then happen in the right place.
5. The potential of meaningful engagement
Through strategies like expanding the role of Parks and Recreation, or developing respite centres, civic workers have become a sort of second responders with added responsibilities. For this reason, Leilani Farha shared the protocol she co-authored. Although many are working on it, there are a lack of examples of positive meaningful engagement with unhoused people. Therefore, compassion and training in harm reduction should be tools that these civic workers have when trying to help. By moving beyond the narrative of people in encampments as criminals, we can begin to learn about each other’s stories.
Note aux lecteurs: Cette session vidéo a été transcrite à l'aide d'un logiciel de transcription automatique. L'édition manuelle a été entreprise dans le but d'améliorer la lisibilité et la clarté. Les questions ou préoccupations concernant la transcription peuvent être adressées à email@example.com avec «transcription» dans la ligne d'objet.
Transcription du chat
Note au lecteur: les commentaires de chat ont été modifiés pour plus de lisibilité. Le texte n'a pas été modifié pour l'orthographe ou la grammaire. Pour toute question ou préoccupation, veuillez contacter firstname.lastname@example.org avec "Commentaires de chat" dans le sujet lin
De l'Institut urbain du Canada: Vous pouvez trouver des transcriptions et des enregistrements de nos webinaires d'aujourd'hui et de tous nos webinaires à https://canurb.org/citytalk